Something remarkable has been happening in Israeli culture in recent years. Artists whose audiences are not necessarily religious—in sociological terms, most of them are not observant—are filling concert halls and stadiums with thousands of people singing about Hashem: about repentance, faith, blessing, and our dependence upon Him.
Last week I saw a clip from a Hanan Ben Ari concert. Thousands of people stood packed together, singing in unison: “Return us to You, Hashem, and we shall return; renew our days as of old.” It did not feel merely like a musical performance, nor like a distant cultural gesture. It felt almost like prayer. I mentioned the clip in my Shabbat Shuva derasha and found myself struggling to hold back tears.
We are living in a remarkable generation, marked by an unmistakable thirst: a generation in which many Jews who do not define themselves as “religious” are reaching once again for the language of faith, prayer, and closeness to Hashem. One can see it in music, in Selichot—some two million people have visited the Old City in recent weeks for Selichot—in public discourse, and in the broader search for meaning and for a deeper form of Jewish belonging. Something is moving within the Jewish people.
When Jews who have lived at a distance from the world of Torah begin to thirst for prayer, faith, and Jewish belonging, the first question is not whether they are becoming more like us. The first question is whether we are capable of becoming a home for that thirst.
The question is whether we know how to recognize the moment, and whether we are worthy of it. The return we are witnessing is not a victory lap for the religious, nor proof that “they” are finally discovering that “we” were right. If anything, it places a new demand upon us. When Jews who have lived at a distance from the world of Torah begin to thirst for prayer, faith, and Jewish belonging, the first question is not whether they are becoming more like us. The first question is whether we are capable of becoming a home for that thirst.
***
On the eve of Yom Kippur, I spoke with someone who lives in Bnei Brak. I asked what the rabbi had spoken about in his Shabbat Shuva derasha. He told me that the sermon had focused on the idea that all goodness and blessing in the world come through the power of Torah, whereas secular Jews, through their struggle against Torah, damage that source of blessing and block the channels through which Divine abundance reaches the world.
I remember thinking how sad this was. On the eve of Yom Kippur, of all times—a day when we stand before Hashem asking for compassion, and when our spiritual work is to cultivate compassion and judge others favorably—a rabbi in Israel chose to inspire his listeners through such a simple division: we are good, they are bad; we are the source of blessing, they are the ones who obstruct it.
The tragedy was not merely the harshness toward secular Jews. It was that, on the threshold of Yom Kippur, teshuva itself had been turned into a confirmation of our own righteousness. Yet Yom Kippur teaches us precisely the opposite. No community enters the day as prosecutor while another stands in the dock. We all stand before the same Judge. We all confess. We all beat our chests. We all ask for (and receive) Divine compassion; we all return.
There is no need to deny the disagreements that divide Israeli society. They are real, and at times painful: religion and state, education, military service, Jewish identity, and the place of Torah in the public sphere. There is also genuine hostility, sometimes severe, toward Charedi society and toward the Torah world. But anyone who looks at the Jewish people only through the prism of these conflicts risks missing the larger picture.
The larger picture is that the Jewish people are returning.
Israeli culture, which for many years knew how to speak about Judaism mainly through the languages of conflict, memory, or folklore, is beginning once again to speak the language of faith.
Not all in the same way, not all at the same pace, and not all toward precisely the same destination. But something deep is taking place. Israeli culture, which for many years knew how to speak about Judaism mainly through the languages of conflict, memory, or folklore, is beginning once again to speak the language of faith. Religious and nonreligious artists alike speak openly about Hashem, without apology. People sing verses from Tanach. Young Israelis seek out prayer. Words such as teshuva, faith, and rachamim are returning to the center of public culture, woven into an Israeli society whose spiritual vocabulary itself appears to be changing.
In such a moment, the responsibility upon us is especially great. We can respond with suspicion and fear. We can dismiss the phenomenon as shallow, sentimental, kitschy, or external, and reassure ourselves that “they” will never really understand. We can continue to define Charedi identity through the line separating us from them, through a story in which we are the bearers of goodness and holiness while the other side represents threat, corruption, and danger.
Or we can understand that perhaps the great Charedi challenge of this generation is no longer only how to preserve ourselves, but how to become worthy of the Torah we have preserved.
For generations, Charedi society invested extraordinary energy in building walls strong enough to protect Torah life. It demanded much wisdom and sacrifice, and reached enormous historical achievement. But eventually one must ask what the walls were built for. Was the goal merely that Torah should survive safely inside them, or was it also that a living Torah, preserved in all its depth and integrity, should one day be able to illuminate a people thirsting beyond them?
We can look at what is happening around us and see “them” edging a little closer toward what is “ours.” Or we can see a great people seeking to draw closer to its roots—a people that has passed through years of unbearable difficulty, that has encountered loss, courage, self-sacrifice, and fear at close range, and that is searching anew for a language capable of carrying all of that. In that picture, these are not outsiders approaching our territory, but brothers and sisters moving, in different ways, toward a shared source.
We can dismiss the phenomenon as shallow, sentimental, kitschy, or external, and reassure ourselves that “they” will never really understand. […] Or we can understand that perhaps the great Charedi challenge of this generation is no longer only how to preserve ourselves, but how to become worthy of the Torah we have preserved.
If that is the picture, then the Charedi role changes as well. The task is not to withdraw further, but to become worthy of being a destination; not to look down upon others, but to illuminate; not to say “we told you so,” but to open a door. The question is no longer how many additional layers can be added to the wall, but how the depth and beauty of the Torah world can respond to the immense Jewish thirst now revealing itself around us.
***
For that to happen, however, we ourselves need to change. A Charedi society built entirely around separation will struggle to meet a people seeking closeness. A society that repeatedly tells itself that it is good because others are bad will fail to recognize the good awakening beyond its own boundaries. If our entire language is one of “us” and “them,” we will never truly learn to speak the language of Amcha Yisrael.
After all, we too are returning. We too have things for which we must repent. Yom Kippur was not given so that we might catalogue the sins of others, but so that we might look at ourselves. Perhaps part of the Charedi reckoning of this generation is to ask whether we have become too accustomed to defining holiness through distance; whether preservation has sometimes hardened into estrangement; whether we have become so practiced at identifying the dangers beyond our walls that we have lost the ability to recognize the sparks of holiness awakening there.
And perhaps we need to remember something even more basic: Torah was not given to a sector. It was given to a people.
Sukkot arrives immediately after Yom Kippur, and perhaps no festival is better suited to this reflection. Chazal teach that all Israel are “fit to dwell in a single sukkah.” Throughout the year we live in separate homes, separate communities, separate institutions, and often within separate narratives about who we are and who the others are. The Sukkah does not demand that all Jews become identical. It does not erase differences of practice, community, worldview, or conviction. But it places those differences beneath a larger belonging. For seven days, the walls that ordinarily define us become thin and temporary, while the shelter of the Shechinah becomes the deeper reality.
Our boundaries matter, but they are not the deepest truth about us. The deepest truth is that we are one people standing before one God.
Perhaps that is precisely the lesson we need now. Our boundaries matter, but they are not the deepest truth about us. The deepest truth is that we are one people standing before one God. The call of the hour is therefore not to erase difference, but to place difference within a larger covenant; not to abandon the distinctiveness of Charedi life, but to understand that such distinctiveness can no longer be sustained through a story of estrangement alone.
The choice before us is what kind of Charedi society we wish to become: one that continues to nourish itself through opposition to others, or one capable of recognizing the great movement taking place within the Jewish people, rejoicing in it, and accepting responsibility for it. One that experiences every weakening of a wall as a threat, or one that trusts Torah enough to believe that its light can shine beyond the boundaries we already know.
***
After writing these lines, I received a post from a Jewish man living in Kibbutz Lahav, a kibbutz founded by Hashomer Hatzair, who at the age of forty-one participated in Yom Kippur prayers for the first time in his life. To complete the minyan, members of Kibbutz Shomria joined them—a religious kibbutz established by evacuees from Gush Katif.
Before Ne’ilah, the cantor, Lior, removed his white Yom Kippur clothes and put on his IDF uniform—the uniform of his seventh round of reserve duty since October 7. “These clothes,” he said, “are the most exact and appropriate clothes for me to wear.”
The post continued:
“Dozens upon dozens of kibbutz members gathered for Ne’ilah. They listened to the melodies, the piyyutim, and the sound of the shofar. I held my son close to me and felt that this was a meaningful point in my life’s journey. […]
“Yesterday, people from across the political spectrum prayed together at Kibbutz Lahav—some who will vote for Yair Golan, others who will vote for Ben Gvir. But during Kol Nidrei, during Adon HaSelihot, during the sounding of the shofar—it simply did not matter to anyone.”
The disagreements had not disappeared. Nobody had surrendered his politics, biography, or community. Yet for a few hours, something deeper became visible: beneath the arguments, beneath the sectors, beneath the separate Israeli tribes, there remained a shared language of prayer and a shared place before Hashem.
And so, once again, thousands of Jews are singing: “Return us to You, Hashem, and we shall return.”
This is not merely a line from a song. It is a call—certainly to those rediscovering the language of faith, but no less to those of us who have carried that language all along.
With Hashem’s help, may we be worthy of answering it.
This article deeply touched my heart. Such beauty in the soul of every Jew, and that beauty is now coming to light! It feels as though a quiet truth is finally being spoken out loud, and it resonates deeply. There is a powerful warmth in knowing that we are experiencing this profound shift together. It fills me with so much hope to think about where this shared journey of the soul will lead us.